BAYC Founder Joins Royalty Conversation

BAYC Founder Joins Royalty Conversation

Wylie Aronow, a co-founder of Yuga Labs and Bored Ape Yacht Club, entered the royalty conversation with a lengthy Substack post published on Tuesday morning from his personal platform. 

Aronow, who goes by GordonGoner on social media, started his post with two "facts" about royalties and the NFT ecosystem:

1) The NFT ecosystem would be a tiny fraction of what it is today if it weren't for creator royalties. 

2) The leading marketplaces of the past couple years would be nowhere if they hadn’t supported them.

While both points could be argued by those on either side of the royalty argument, Aronow specifically is well-equipped to make the second claim. 

The Bored Ape Yacht Club NFT collection alone has traded more than 679,000 ETH on the OpenSea marketplace, generating nearly 17,000 ETH for OpenSea since the collection launched. Even at current ETH prices that is more than $24 million in marketplace fees for OpenSea. 

Yuga Labs opted to utilize a 2.5 percent royalty on the Bored Ape collection, generating roughly the same amount of ETH in secondary trading volumes as part of the creator royalties. 

"Basically we said: If OpenSea was going to take that much off the top for other people wanting to join the club we created, why shouldn’t we?" writes Aronow..."It’s a gift to be directly supported by the market’s continued demand for your work."

Demand though may no longer result in royalty payments for creators as marketplaces aim to maintain market share. 

In August Ethereum-based NFT marketplace X2Y2 made royalty payments optional on its platform. Then in October, Solana's leading NFT marketplace followed suit. 

And while OpenSea in particular has spoken out on protecting and enforcing creator royalties, many of web3's strongest voices are not satisfied - including Aronow. 

Aronow's Proposed Solution

Instead of enacting blacklists for trading collections on marketplaces that don't enforce royalties, Aronow's proposed solution involves allowlists "that enable trading between normal wallets and specifically allows marketplaces that respect royalties."

His proposed solution works like this:

  1. When a transfer comes in, check if it’s a regular wallet (EOA) making the request, or a smart contract

  2. If it’s an EOA (again, a normal wallet), then you let it go through. Marketplaces don’t use EOAs, so this is either someone making an over-the-counter trade, or moving their own NFTs around. You can’t tell the difference; let it through.

  3. If it’s a smart contract that has initiated this transfer, check against an oracle of contracts that are known to respect royalties. If it matches, let it go through. If not, nope. 

The aforementioned process ensures that the transfer of an asset is merely a normal wallet trade or a smart contract interaction with a verified "good actor" or royalty-respecting contract. 

This does have some potential drawbacks though, according to Aronow. Most notably that new NFT marketplaces will be difficult to spin up because their smart contracts would need to be allowlisted and the allowlist must be ever-maintained by an oracle. 

And to those claiming that this process is not decentralized in spirit...."That’s bullshit," says Aronow...."It’s not impossible to create a healthy allowlist process, especially if all normal wallet-to-wallet transfers are enabled by default and can’t be prohibited."

This is a developing story, Lucky Trader will add to it as more details emerge.

More about Bored Ape Yacht Club

Arguably the most successful NFT project, the Bored Ape Yacht Club (BAYC), is a collection of 10,000 uniquely generated bored apes that are stored on the Ethereum blockchain. Launched on April 23, Bored Ape Yacht Club had a mint price of 0.08 ETH and the collection sold out on April 30, 2021. Since its launch, the project has dropped multiple companion collections including Bored Ape Kennel Club, Mutant Ape Yacht Club, and Otherdeed for Otherside, and has helped onboard a number of high profile and celebrity collectors to the NFT ecosystem.

At the time of publish, the Bored Ape Yacht Club floor price sits at 66.968 ETH, and has stayed relatively flat over the past 24 hours on 1676 ETH volume of transactions. Over the last 30 days, 27 sharp wallets have sold 30 NFTs and 29 sharp wallets have bought 29 NFTs in the Bored Ape Yacht Club collection. Catch up on other recent Bored Ape Yacht Club news here.

Recent Bored Ape Yacht Club Sales

#441sold at 12/09 9:12pm for
#5139sold at 12/09 8:12pm for
#6206sold at 12/09 4:12pm for
#9953sold at 12/09 2:12pm for
#9953sold at 12/09 10:12am for

Recent Bored Ape Yacht Club Listings

#8976listed at 12/09 10:12pm for
#2217listed at 12/09 10:12pm for
#5546listed at 12/09 10:12pm for
#8477listed at 12/09 10:12pm for
#8477listed at 12/09 10:12pm for
Disclaimer: The author or members of the Lucky Trader staff may own NFTs discussed in this post. Furthermore, the information contained on this website or the Lucky Trader mobile application is not intended as, and shall not be understood or construed as financial advice.
In this post
Related Content
Lucky Trader News on Twitter
Get alerts the moment news breaks with the Lucky Trader app.